level at the GUT scale. Due to SUSY nonrenormalization
theorems [57], in the exact SUSY limit this term cannot be
regenerated radiatively at low energies, so ˜μ is identically
zero and was not included in the superpotential given by
Eq. (21). So, the resulting superpotential contains only
fundamental superfields coming from L, Q
L
, and Q
R
and is
indeed invariant under SUð3Þ
F
.
In the GUT-scale theory, a complex λ
78
would be the
only source of LR-parity violation. In the low-energy
theory this should lead to y
3
≠ y
4
. Otherwise, y
3
¼ y
4
and after the matching is performed we can always make
any y
1;2;3;4
real by field redefinitions. The same argument
applies for the equality of the corresponding LR gauge
couplings for SUð2Þ
L;R
×Uð1Þ
L;R
symmetries.
Since we now have an effective LR-symmetric SUSY
model with a Uð1Þ
L;R
symmetry, there is a possibility of
having gauge kinetic mixing. The Uð1Þ
L;R
D-term con-
tribution to the Lagrangian is given by
L ⊃
1
2
ðχD
L
D
R
þD
2
L
þD
2
R
Þ− κðD
L
− D
R
ÞþX
L
D
L
þX
R
D
R
;
ð22Þ
where the terms proportional to κ are the Fayet-Iliopoulos
terms, while the D-terms and the expressions for X
L;R
are
shown in Appendix D3b.
The values of the parameters fy
1;2;3;4
;g
C
;g
L;R
;g
0
L;R
; χ; κg
in the LR-symmetric SUSY theory are determined by the
values of the parameters fλ
27
; λ
78
;g
U
;vg in the high-scale
trinification theory at the GUT-scale boundary through a
matching procedure.
2
Regarding the RG evolution of the
couplings, we note that the only dimensionful parameter in
the effective theory is the Fayet-Iliopoulos parameter κ.
This means that β
κ
∝ κ so that if κ ¼ 0 at the matching
scale (which is true, at least, at tree level), then κ will
remain zero throughout the RG flow yielding no sponta-
neous SUSY breaking. Thus, we stick to the concept of soft
SUSY breaking in what follows.
IV. SOFTLY BROKEN SUSY
In this section we describe the details of adding
soft SUSY-breaking terms before the SHUT symmetry
is broken spontaneously by adjoint field VEVs. One
of the most important results is treated in Sec. IV B,
where it is shown that the symmetry breakings below
the GUT scale are triggered solely by the soft SUSY-
breaking sector. This, in turn, allows for a strong hierarchy
between the GUT scale and the scale of the following
VEVs.
A. The soft SUSY-breaking Lagrangian
The soft SUSY-breaking scalar potential terms respect-
ing the imposed G
333f3g
symmetry are bilinear and trilinear
interactions given by
V
G
soft
¼
m
2
27
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
r
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
r
þ m
2
78
˜
Δ
a
L
˜
Δ
a
L
þ
1
2
b
78
˜
Δ
a
L
˜
Δ
a
L
þ c:c
þ d
abc
1
3!
A
78
˜
Δ
a
L
˜
Δ
b
L
˜
Δ
c
L
þ
1
2
C
78
˜
Δ
a
L
˜
Δ
b
L
˜
Δ
c
L
þ c:c:
þ½A
G
˜
Δ
a
L
ðT
a
Þ
l
1
l
2
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
1
r
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
2
r
þ A
¯
G
˜
Δ
a
R
ðT
a
Þ
r
2
r
1
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
r
1
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
r
2
þ c:c:þðZ
ðLRCÞ
3
permutationsÞ
þ½A
27
ε
ijk
ð
˜
Q
i
L
Þ
x
l
ð
˜
Q
j
R
Þ
r
x
ð
˜
L
k
Þ
l
r
þ c:c:; ð23Þ
for the gauge adjoints and pure tritriplet terms, and
V
F
soft
¼ m
2
1
˜
Δ
a
F
˜
Δ
a
F
þ
1
2
b
1
˜
Δ
a
F
˜
Δ
a
F
þ c:c
þ d
abc
1
3!
A
1
˜
Δ
a
F
˜
Δ
b
F
˜
Δ
c
F
þ
1
2
C
1
˜
Δ
a
F
˜
Δ
b
F
˜
Δ
c
F
þ c:c:
þ½A
F
˜
Δ
a
F
ðT
a
Þ
i
j
ð
˜
L
i
Þ
l
r
ð
˜
L
j
Þ
l
r
þ c:c: þðZ
ðLRCÞ
3
permutationsÞ ð24Þ
for the family adjoint. All parameters here are assumed to
be real for simplicity. We note that, although trilinear terms
with the gauge singlets (such as
˜
Δ
F
˜
Δ
F
˜
Δ
F
above) are not in
general soft, due to the family symmetry and the fact that
P
a
d
aab
¼ 0, the dangerous tadpole diagrams do indeed
cancel and do not lead to quadratic divergences.
The terms in Eqs. (23) and (24), which account for the most
general soft SUSY-breaking scalar potential consistent with
G
333f3g
and real parameters, also respect the accidental
Uð1Þ
W
×Uð1Þ
B
symmetry of the original SUSY theory.
Ho we v er, accidental LR parity is, in general, softly broken
as long as A
G
≠ A
¯
G
, and this breaking can then be transmitted
to the other sectors of the effective theory radiatively (e.g., via
RG ev olution and radiativ e corrections at the matching scale).
The only dimensionful parameters entering in the tree-
level tritriplet masses come from soft SUSY-breaking
2
Before adding soft SUSY-breaking interactions, Δ
F
is com-
pletely decoupled from the fundamental sector when taking
SUð3Þ
F
to be global, meaning that λ
1
and v
F
do not enter in
the matching conditions .
SCALE HIERARCHIES, SYMMETRY BREAKING, AND PARTICLE … PHYS. REV. D 99, 035041 (2019)
035041-7