
Physics Letters B 781 (2018) 206–212
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Physics Letters B
www.elsevier.com/locate/physletb
A resolution of the inclusive flavor-breaking τ |V
us
| puzzle
Renwick J. Hudspith
a
, Randy Lewis
a
, Kim Maltman
b,∗,1
, James Zanotti
c
a
Department of Physics and Astronomy, York University, 4700 Keele St., Toronto, ON, M3J 1P3, Canada
b
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, York University, 4700 Keele St., Toronto, ON, M3J 1P3, Canada
c
CSSM, Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received
10 February 2017
Received
in revised form 19 February 2018
Accepted
28 March 2018
Available
online 3 April 2018
Editor:
B. Grinstein
We revisit the puzzle of |V
us
| values obtained from the conventional implementation of hadronic-τ-
decay-based
flavor-breaking finite-energy sum rules lying > 3σ below the expectations of three-family
unitarity. Significant unphysical dependences of |V
us
| on the choice of weight, w, and upper limit, s
0
, of
the experimental spectral integrals entering the analysis are confirmed, and a breakdown of assumptions
made in estimating higher dimension, D > 4, OPE contributions identified as the main source of these
problems. A combination of continuum and lattice results is shown to suggest a new implementation
of the flavor-breaking sum rule approach in which not only |V
us
|, but also D > 4 effective condensates,
are fit to data. Lattice results are also used to clarify how to reliably treat the slowly converging D = 2
OPE
series. The new sum rule implementation is shown to cure the problems of the unphysical w-
and
s
0
-dependence of |V
us
| and to produce results ∼ 0.0020 higher than those of the conventional
implementation employing the same data. With B-factory input, and using, in addition, dispersively
constrained results for the K π branching fractions, we find |V
us
| = 0.2231(27)
exp
(4)
th
, in excellent
agreement with the result from K
3
, and compatible within errors with the expectations of three-family
unitarity, thus resolving the long-standing inclusive τ |V
us
| puzzle.
© 2018 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Funded by SCOAP
3
.
1. Introduction
With |V
ud
| = 0.97417(21) [1]as input and |V
ub
| negligible,
3-family unitary implies |V
us
| = 0.2258(9). Direct determinations
of |V
us
| from K
3
and [K
μ2
]/[π
μ2
], using recent 2014 Fla-
viaNet
experimental results [2] and 2016 lattice input [3]for
f
+
(0) and f
K
/ f
π
, respectively, yield results, |V
us
| = 0.2231(9)
and 0.2253(7), in agreement with this expectation. In contrast,
the most recent update [4]of the conventional implementation of
the finite-energy sum rule (FESR) determination employing flavor-
breaking
(FB) combinations of inclusive strange and non-strange
hadronic τ decay data [5], yields |V
us
| = 0.2186(21), 3.1σ be-
low
3-family-unitarity expectations. A less discrepant, but still low,
result, 0.2207(27), was obtained in Ref. [6]using the same conven-
tional
implementation but somewhat higher input K π branching
fractions (resulting from an analysis of K π data imposing addi-
*
Corresponding author.
E-mail
addresses: renwick.james .hudspith @gmail .com (R.J. Hudspith),
randy.lewis @yorku .ca (R. Lewis), kmaltman @yorku .ca (K. Maltman),
james .zanotti @adelaide .edu .au (J. Zanotti).
1
Alternate address: CSSM, Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Ade-
laide,
SA 5005, Australia.
tional dispersive constraints on the timelike K π form factors [6]).
The general FB FESR framework whose conventional implementa-
tion
produces these low |V
us
| results is outlined below.
In
the Standard Model, the differential distributions, d R
V / A;ij
/ds,
for flavor ij = ud, us, vector (V) or axial-vector (A) current-
mediated
decays, with R
V / A;ij
defined by R
V / A;ij
≡ [τ
−
→
ν
τ
hadrons
V / A;ij
(γ )]/[τ
−
→ ν
τ
e
−
¯
ν
e
(γ )], are related to the spec-
tral
functions, ρ
( J )
V / A;ij
, of the J = 0, 1scalar polarizations,
( J )
V / A;ij
,
of the corresponding current–current two-point functions, by [7]
dR
V / A;ij
ds
=
12π
2
|V
ij
|
2
S
EW
m
2
τ
w
τ
(y
τ
)ρ
(0+1)
V / A;ij
(s)
−
w
L
(y
τ
)ρ
(0)
V / A;ij
(s)
≡
12π
2
|V
ij
|
2
S
EW
m
2
τ
(
1 − y
τ
)
2
˜
ρ
V / A;ij
(s), (1)
where y
τ
= s/m
2
τ
, w
τ
(y) = (1 − y)
2
(1 + 2y), w
L
(y) = 2 y(1 − y)
2
,
S
EW
is a known short-distance electroweak correction [8], and V
ij
is the flavor ij CKM matrix element. The J = 0spectral functions,
ρ
(0)
A;ud,us
(s), are dominated by the accurately known, chirally un-
suppressed
π and K pole contributions. The remaining, continuum
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2018.03.074
0370-2693/
© 2018 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Funded by
SCOAP
3
.