Wi-Fi与蓝牙：频段与应用冲突分析

2星需积分: 10 180 浏览量更新于2024-09-15 收藏 205KB PDF 举报

Wi-Fi与蓝牙是两种常见的短距离无线通信技术，分别应用于局域网（WLAN）和无线个人局域网（WPAN）领域。Wi-Fi以其高速数据传输能力而广受欢迎，主要标准包括802.11b、802.11a和802.11g。802.11b使用2.4GHz频段，最大传输速度可达11Mbps；802.11a在5.8GHz频段运行，支持高达54Mbps的速率，适合需要高速传输的应用；802.11g也在2.4GHz工作，标准模式下为54Mbps，但超级G模式可提升至108Mbps。相比之下，蓝牙技术主要用于连接便携式设备，如蓝牙耳机、手机和掌上电脑之间的数据传输，其传输带宽相对较低，通常为1Mbps。蓝牙的有效传输范围理论值约为10米，特别适合于低功耗、短距离的数据交换。然而，随着Wi-Fi和蓝牙设备的广泛部署，它们在同一个干扰范围内共存时，频道冲突问题变得越来越严重。研究论文"Modeling Channel Conflict Probabilities between IEEE 802.11 Band IEEE 802.15.1 Networks"深入探讨了这两个技术标准的共存问题。该论文主要关注一个IEEE 802.15.1网络（蓝牙）与一个或多个IEEE 802.11b、11a或11g网络（Wi-Fi）的非冲突频道分配概率。研究结果显示，随着Wi-Fi网络数量的增加，频道冲突的可能性也随之上升。作者提出的分析模型简单实用，对于理解其他无线技术之间的共存问题同样具有指导意义，前提条件是这些技术的频道分配机制相似。这对于无线设备制造商、网络规划者以及系统优化者来说，是理解和解决Wi-Fi与蓝牙共存问题的重要参考。通过了解和应用这些模型，可以有效地管理网络资源，减少干扰，提高整体无线通信系统的效率和稳定性。

Modeling Channel Conﬂict Probabilities between

IEEE 802.11b and IEEE 802.15.1 Networks

Ling-Jyh Chen and Ting-Kai Huang

Institute of Information Science, Academia Sinica

Email: {cclljj,tkhuang}@iis.sinica.edu.tw

Abstract— With the increasingly deployed Wireless Lo-

cal/Personal Area Network (WLAN/WPAN) devices, channel

conﬂict has become very frequent and severe when one

WLAN/WPAN technology coexists with other WLAN/WPAN

technologies in the same interfering range. In this paper, we

study the coexistence issue between the most prevalent WLAN

and WPAN technologies, namely the IEEE 802.11b and IEEE

802.15.1 standards. We present analytical models on the non-

conﬂicting channel allocation probabilities, focusing on the co-

existence scenarios of one IEEE 802.15.1 network coexisting

with one or multiple IEEE 802.11b networks. The results show

that channel allocation conﬂicts does occur more frequently as

the number of IEEE 802.11b networks increases. Moreover, the

proposed analytical model in this letter is simple and applicable

to other wireless technologies, as long as the channel allocation

mechanisms are known.

I. INTRODUCTION

Wireless Local/Personal Area Network (WLAN/WPAN)

technologies have fueled the development as well as the

wide proliferation of wireless portable devices (e.g., laptops,

PDAs, smart phones, portable media players, etc.). Yet, the

popularity of these wireless devices has resulted in many forms

of frequency spectrum clash amongst the different wireless

technologies. To understand the performance of these wireless

devices in different interference situations, it is increasingly

important to study the coexistence issue amongst the existing

wireless technologies.

Since the two most widely deployed WLAN and WPAN

technologies (i.e., IEEE 802.11b and IEEE 802.15.1) both op-

erate in the same 2.4GHz ISM (Industrial-Scientiﬁc-Medical)

frequency band, channel allocation conﬂicts are inevitable

when they coexist within the same radio range. The coexis-

tence issues will become even severe while these technologies

also coexist with other 2.4GHz based wireless/radio technolo-

gies (e.g. IEEE 802.15.3 devices [1], IEEE 802.15.4 devices

[2], cordless phone, microwave oven, etc.). It soon becomes

important to understand the characteristics of each channel

allocation scheme and how each channel allocation scheme

interacts with the others. Table I summarizes some of the

relevant properties of the wireless standards mentioned above.

The coexistence issue between 2.4GHz-based wireless tech-

nologies has been extensively studied. [3] ﬁrst performed

a systematical study on the coexistence of IEEE 802.11b

This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Council

under grant number NSC 96-2623-7-001-004-D.

TABLE I

WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES IN 2.4GHZ ISM FREQUENCY BAND.

IEEE Standard 802.11b/g 802.15.1 802.15.3 802.15.4

Frequency Band 2.4GHz 2.4GHz 2.4GHz 2.4GHz

rcv Bandwidth 22MHz 1MHz 15MHz 2MHz

Number of Channels 11 79 5 16

Max Rate (Mbps) 11/54 0.72 55 0.25

Transmission Range 100m 10m 10m 20m

Applications WLAN WPAN HR-WPAN LR-WPAN

and Bluetooth devices via testbed measurements, and [4] has

studied the coexistence of Bluetooth and microwave ovens by

measuring the channel error rates of Bluetooth devices. In ad-

dition, analytical models for the coexistence of Bluetooth and

IEEE 802.11b have also been proposed in [5] [6] [7] at various

conﬁguration scenarios, and the discussion on the coexistence

issue between IEEE 802.11 and the IEEE 802.15 based WPAN

technologies has been included in IEEE standards (e.g., the

IEEE 802.15.2 standard [9]). Nonetheless, previous analytical

work assumed operating channels are already conﬂicted when

modeling error rates between different wireless technologies,

while a detailed study on modeling the probabilities of channel

conﬂicts on a random view basis is still lacking.

In this paper, we study coexistence issues between two

of the most widely deployed WLAN and WPAN technolo-

gies, namely the IEEE 802.11b [10] and IEEE 802.15.1 [11]

standards. Unlike previous work [7] [5] [6] [3], which has

extensively studied the impact of wireless interference on the

packet error rate and/or data throughput based on an implicit

assumption that wireless channels are already conﬂicted, it

is the interest of this paper to study the “channel conﬂict

probability” when one wireless technology ‘meets’ the other

one in the same interfering range on a random view basis.

Of course, the results of our work could be combined with

previous work to relax that conﬂicted channels assumption and

derive the packet error rate and/or expected data throughput.

Finally, it should also be mentioned that the analysis presented

in this letter is also useful in calculating the channel collision

probability for other wireless technologies as long as their

channel allocation mechanisms are known.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Section II,

we present an brief overview of the IEEE 802.11b and IEEE

802.15.1 technologies and their channel allocation schemes. In

Section III, we present analysis on the probability of channel

collision between different pairing of wireless technologies.

下载后可阅读完整内容，剩余3页未读，立即下载

apehanger

粉丝: 0

Wi-Fi与蓝牙：频段与应用冲突分析

wi-fi world

与Wi-Fi直接连接-Connecting with Wi-Fi Direct

Wi-Fi和蓝牙5技术谁更强?Wi-Fi大战蓝牙5

Wi-Fi与蓝牙技术详解

Wi-Fi与蓝牙4.0的战争

华山论剑 Wi-Fi与蓝牙4.0的战斗

通信与网络中的Wi-Fi与蓝牙4.0的战争

通信与网络中的华山论剑 Wi-Fi与蓝牙4.0的战斗

2.4GHz无线技术标准：ZigBee抗干扰与Wi-Fi、蓝牙比较

Android系统中Wi-Fi与蓝牙移植指南

最新资源