Robust and low-cost interrogation technique for
integrated photonic biochemical sensors based
on Mach–Zehnder interferometers
V. Toccafondo
1,
* and C. J. Oton
2
1
Consorzio Nazionale Interuniversitario per le Telecomunicazioni, Via G. Moruzzi 1, 56124 Pisa, Italy
2
Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna, Via G. Moruzzi 1, 56124 Pisa, Italy
*Corresponding author: veronica.toccafondo@cnit.it
Received February 20, 2015; revised February 9, 2016; accepted February 16, 2016;
posted February 18, 2016 (Doc. ID 254169); published March 14, 2016
We describe and experimentally demonstrate a measuring technique for Mach–Zehnder interferometer (MZI)
based integrated photonic biochemical sensors. Our technique is based on the direct measurement of phase
changes between the arms of the MZI, achieved by signal modulation on one of the arms of the interferometer
together with pseudoheterodyne detection, and it allows us to avoid the use of costly equipment such as tunable
light sources or spectrum analyzers. The obtained output signal is intrinsically independent of wavelength, power
variations, and global thermal variations, making it extremely robust and adequate for use in real conditions. Using
a silicon-on-insulator MZI, we demonstrate the real-time monitoring of refractive index variations and achieve a
detection limit of 4.1 × 10
−6
refractive index units (RIU). © 2016 Chinese Laser Press
OCIS codes: (130.6010) Sensors; (130.3120) Integrated optics devices; (060.2840) Heterodyne.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1364/PRJ.4.000057
1. INTRODUCTION
Silicon photonics [1] is becoming a very attractive technology
for the realization of photonic biosensors aimed at the detec-
tion of proteins, antibodies, DNA, contaminants, and so forth.
The main reason for this is their potential for mass production
because of being compatible with standard CMOS processes,
which would yield a very low cost per device while maintain-
ing a high sensing performance. However, at the moment they
are hardly employed outside academic research and are strug-
gling to find an appropriate market [2]. We believe that this is
due to several factors, among which is the very conservative
medical and biological environment, into which it is difficult
to introduce disruptive technology, or the fact that many of
those sensors rely on the use of expensive devices, such as
tunable lasers or optical spectrum analyzers, to perform the
readout of the sensor [2]. Moreover it is difficult to find inte-
grated photonic biosensors which are really robust to environ-
mental changes, such as the temperature of the surrounding
medium or the power and wavelength fluctuations of the light
source. Typically employed photonic structures include ring
resonators [3], photonic crystals [4], microdisks [5], or Mach–
Zehnder interferometers (MZIs) [6]. All these are based on
evanescent wave sensing and exhibit a change in their re-
sponse when the refractive index n
eff
of the surrounding
medium changes. The first three rely on the detection of a
change in the transmission spectrum of the device when n
eff
changes. In MZI-based sensors the phase difference induced
by n
eff
variations over one of the two interferometer arms
yields a modulation of the interferometric conditions at the
device output [2,6]. Typically this intensity variation is what
is measured when using MZI-based sensors, but it presents
some drawbacks, such as the change in sensitivity depending
on the interferometric condition (maximum around the quad-
rature points, but very low at the vertices), and the intrinsic
difficulty in distinguishing phase changes from intensity
variations. A measuring technique allowing us to avoid this
problem and in which the signal going through one of the MZI
arms is electrically modulated was already proposed in [7],
although the performance of the device with the modulation
elements was not demonstrated. In that paper, the interroga-
tion was based on a different technique in which a time delay
between a trigger and the quadrature point was monitored. In
[8] a technique was proposed for MZI interrogation based on
phase modulation of the laser source. However, that tech-
nique requires a very asymmetric MZI which produces a phase
response that is very sensitive to thermal fluctuations and
wavelength variations of the source.
In this paper we propose a technique based on pseudohe-
terodyne phase demodulation [9], capable of extracting the
phase variations in a robust way without having to tune the
laser source or use spectral analysis. In our experiment we
have used a dual-phase lock-in amplifier (LIA) for phase
demodulation, although it is expected that simpler phase-
demodulation components could be used too, which would
avoid the need of lock-in amplification. Our technique is in-
trinsically immune to power, temperature, and wavelength
fluctuations, and it allows the use of low-cost instruments
to perform the read-out, making it very promising for the
realization of low-cost point-of-care devices.
2. CONCEPT
The phase demodulation technique consists of the introduc-
tion of a periodic phase variation with a linear sawtooth with
a 2π amplitude, which produces an effect equivalent to a
V. Toccafondo and C. J. Oton Vol. 4, No. 2 / April 2016 / Photon. Res. 57
2327-9125/16/020057-04 © 2016 Chinese Laser Press