Metric Space of Collider Events
Patrick T. Komiske,
*
Eric M. Metodiev,
†
and Jesse Thaler
‡
Center for Theoretical Physics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA
and Department of Physics, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA
(Received 15 February 2019; published 26 July 2019)
When are two collider events similar? Despite the simplicity and generality of this question, there is no
established notion of the distance between two events. To address this question, we develop a metric for the
space of collider events based on the earth mover’s distance: the “work” required to rearrange the radiation
pattern of one event into another. We expose interesting connections between this metric and the structure
of infrared- and collinear-safe observables, providing a novel technique to quantify event modifications due
to hadronization, pileup, and detector effects. We showcase how this metrization unlocks powerful new
tools for analyzing and visualizing collider data without relying upon a choice of observables. More
broadly, this framework paves the way for data-driven collider phenomenology without specialized
observables or machine learning models.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.123.041801
High-energy particle collisions produce a tremendous
number of intricately correlated particles, especially when
energetic quarks and gluons are involved. Behind this
apparent complexity, however, the overall flow of energy
in an event is a robust memory of its simpler partonic
origins [1–8]. Surprisingly, no definition of the similarity
between events presently exists that sharply captures this
correspondence. In the absence of a metric, efforts typically
fall back upon ad hoc methods such as comparing specific
observables [9–13] or matching the pixels of calorimeter
images [13–17]. These approaches suffer from significant
pathologies: disparate event topologies can give rise to
identical observable values, while pixels lack stability
under small perturbations. A theoretically and experimen-
tally robust definition of the “distance” between events
would profoundly expand our ability to explore the
structure of collider data and unlock entirely new ways
to probe events.
In this Letter, we advocate for the earth (or energy)
mover’s distance (EMD) [18–22] as a metric for the space
of collider events. We propose a variant of the EMD,
inspired by Refs. [21,22], that allows events with different
total energies to be sensibly compared. The EMD is the
minimum “work” required to rearrange one event E into
the other E
0
by movements of energy f
ij
from particle i in
one event to particle j in the other:
EMDðE; E
0
Þ¼ min
ff
ij
≥0g
X
ij
f
ij
θ
ij
R
þ
X
i
E
i
−
X
j
E
0
j
;
X
j
f
ij
≤ E
i
;
X
i
f
ij
≤ E
0
j
;
X
ij
f
ij
¼ E
min
; ð1Þ
where i and j index particles in events E and E
0
, respec-
tively, E
i
is the particle energy, θ
ij
is an angular distance
FIG. 1. The optimal movement to rearrange one top jet (red)
into another (blue). Particles are shown as points in the rapidity-
azimuth plane with areas proportional to their transverse mo-
menta. Darker lines indicate more transverse momentum move-
ment. The energy mover’s distance in Eq. (1) is the total “work”
required to perform this rearrangement.
Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.
Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to
the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation,
and DOI. Funded by SCOAP
3
.
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 123, 041801 (2019)
Editors' Suggestion Featured in Physics
0031-9007=19=123(4)=041801(7) 041801-1 Published by the American Physical Society