What
Is a
Test
Strategy?
7
«
Service
*
Field returns
•
The
company's "image
of
quality"
Note
that only test,
field
returns,
and
service involve testing
at
all,
and field
returns
do so
only indirectly. Reducing
the
number
of
failures that
get to the
test
process
or the
number
of
products
that
fail
after shipment
to
customers
also
simplifies
test activities, thereby minimizing costs.
Test-strategy
selection goes
far
beyond merely choosing test techniques.
Design issues,
for
example, include bare-board construction.
An
engineer once
described
a
50-layer board
that
was
designed
in
such
a way
that
it
could
not be
easily
repaired.
To
avoid
the
very expensive scrapping
of bad
boards,
his
colleagues bor-
rowed
a
technique
from
designers
of
random access memory (RAM) components
and
large liquid-crystal-display (LCD) panels—they included redundant traces
for
most
of the
board's
internal logic paths. Paths were chosen
by
soft
switches driven
by
on-board components individually programmed
for
each
board.
Although
this solution
was
expensive,
the
board's
$100,000 price
tag
made
such
an
expensive choice viable, especially because
it was the
only approach that
would
work.
Without
the
redundancy,
board
yields would have been unacceptably
low,
and
repair
was
impossible. Unfortunately,
the
solution created another
problem.
The
board's
components contained specific instructions
to
select known-
good paths.
The
bare board
defied
testing without component-level logic. There-
fore,
the
engineers created
a
test
fixture
that meshed with
the
sockets
on the
board
and
mimicked
its
components.
In
addition
to
pass
or
fail
information,
the
test
would
identify
a
successful path, then generate
the
program with which
to
burn
the
"traffic-cop"
devices
as
part
of its
output.
Including
the
redundancy
as a
design
choice mandated
a
particular extremely complicated test strategy. Sometimes test-
strategy
choices reduce
to
"poor"
and
"none."
The
acceptability
of
particular test steps depends
on
whether
the
strategy
is
for
a new or
existing
facility,
product,
product
line,
or
technology.
In an
existing
facility,
is
there adequate
floor
space
for
expansion?
Is the
facility
already running
three
work
shifts,
or can a
change
in
strategy involve merely adding
a
shift?
Test
managers must also decide whether
to
design their
own
test equipment
or buy it
from
commercial vendors, whether they should
try to
"make
do"
with
existing
equipment,
and
whether
new
equipment must
be the
same type
or
from
the
same manufacturer
as the
installed base.
A
test strategy's success
also
depends
on
aspects
of the
overall manufactur-
ing
operation.
For
instance,
how
does
a
product
move
from
test station
to
repair
station
or
from
one
test station
to the
next?
Are
there conveyors
or
other auto-
mated handlers,
or do
people
transfer material manually? Concurrent-engineering
principles
encourage placing portions
of the
manufacturing process physically
close
to one
another, thereby minimizing bottlenecks
and
in-transit
product
damage. This arrangement also encourages employees
who
perform
different
parts
of
the job to
communicate with
one
another, which tends
to
increase manufactur-
ing
efficiencies
and
lower costs.