Macquarie Research Global Infrastructure
25 January 2019 16
We continue to like power-heavy EXC and PEG, given ongoing positive earnings revisions due to
higher utility capex and proposed regulatory changes in the Midwestern power market (PJM).
Yieldcos – CWEN still top pick, but plenty of value in the space despite PCG overhang
It’s been a rough 12 months for US yieldcos. First, FERC’s decision on recovery of income taxes
by cost-of-service pipelines ended growth prospects for numerous MLPs, the only peers of US
yieldcos. Then Ontario’s new Premier decided to cancel hundreds of wind/solar projects under
development. In November, Northern California wildfires further weakened PCG’s financial
standing - the utility is an offtaker of numerous renewable and gas PPAs, including those owned by
CWEN/AY/NEP. Over the last couple of days, S&P and Moody’s downgraded PCG to junk and
until yesterday, PCG was planning to seek bankruptcy protection against up ~US$30bn in
contingent wildfire-related liabilities related to fires from October 2017 and November 2018. As
mentioned above, yesterday the utility was cleared of any wrongdoing related to the largest of the
October 2017 fires (Tubbs) and we won’t know the cause of the November 2018 fire for at least 12
months if not longer. PCG’s bankruptcy would allow the utility to reopen or reject some of its power
purchase agreements, including those for assets held by yieldcos.
We are optimistic about PCG’s eventual financial recovery, but in the meantime CWEN, with 23%
of CAFD linked to PCG PPAs, needs to slow down its growth. GIP, CWEN’s sponsor, should
support the yieldco, but issuing converts won’t work, at least for now. CWEN remains our only
Outperform for yieldcos though we recognize the company may need to talk about the dividend
increase announced on the 3Q18 call.
We liked changes to NEP’s portfolio during 2018 and the inventive convertible equity portfolio
financing. We can even live with NEP’s current valuation if not for some PCG-related overhang as
~17% of NEP’s revenues comes from power purchase agreement with the utility.
We like AY’s improved financing flexibility and growth prospects thanks to Algonquin. Yet, we
should gain certainty on AY’s ‘20+ Spanish cash flows in 2H19 and the company needs to
successfully refinance its ’19 maturities against rising credit spreads and some PCG contract risk;
~16% of AY’s 2019 CAFD is linked to PPA with PCG.
We like TERP’s financial and operational efficiencies, not to mention no financing needs in 2019 or
any real contract exposure to PCG. The renewable tariff reset in Spain should remain an overhang
through at least the summer.
Europe
The European utility index, the SX6P, closed up by 1.8% in 2018, with an improvement of the
index in the last three months of 5.3%. The utility sector has outperformed the Euro Stoxx 600
Index by 14.5% in the last three months and 13.2% in 2018, considering that the general index fell
by 14% in 2018.
There has been a material difference in performance within Europe in the last three months, but
his quarter was not driven by any particular market in Europe, with the exception of the rebound in
Italian stocks. The worst performing sub sector was the European power generators, which were
joined by some of the best performers in H1 18. Best performers in the last three months were the
European infrastructure utilities, joined by most of the Italian names. Southern Europe has seen
good performance both in Italy and in Iberia. The best performance came from Enel, up 17% and
Italgas, up 13.1%, in the last three months.
The key macro themes driving utility performance has been the lower perceived risk of rising
interest rates. This has meant regulated networks have materially outperformed power generation
expose stocks. Bond yields rose steadily from the start of 2018 and, despite the fall in yields in Q4
18, they currently are above the average of 2018. For example, the Italian bond yield is now at
2.9%, above the average of 2.68% of 2018. The regulated utilities sold off heavily from the start of
2018, but have since recovered some of their losses in Q4 18.
Following the lack of agreement on the State Budget and the government challenging fiscal deficit
caps imposed by the EU, the Italian government finally came back to its senses and presented a
State Budget within the EU deficit caps in December. Italian regulated names and municipality
owned utilities have been the best performers in the sector in the same period of time.
Europe utilities are
covered by Jose Ruiz