April 30, 2010 / Vol. 8, Supplement / CHINESE OPTICS LETTERS 1
Coatings and color: the early days
Angus Macleod
Thin Film Center Inc, 2745 E Via Rotonda, Tucson, AZ 85716-5227, USA
E-mail: angus@thinfilmcenter.com
Received Octob er 31, 2009
Color has b een associated with thin films of materials for longer than we know, but, although the effect
was known and observed, it was not fully understood until comparatively recently. It was the 19th Century
b efore the interference effects in thin films that are responsible for their color, were properly recognized.
Then the subjective, human response that is color, had to wait until the 20th Century before objective
metho ds of defining it were accepted. Nowadays, there are many applications where the color of an optical
coating is its most imp ortant attribute. This talk will survey some of the history of the struggle to
understand and master the color of optical coatings. This is inextricably mingled with the history of color
itself and so much of this account deals with the general problem of color.
OCIS co des: 330.0330, 190.0190, 310.0310, 330.1690
doi: 10.3788/COL201008S1.0001.
1. Early history
Color is of immense importance in our daily lives and
it has always been so. Even in the simple act of decid-
ing whether something is safe or ready to eat, color is of
great importance. Rulers have sometimes, as in the cases
of the Emperors of China and of Ancient Rome, reserved
certain colors for their own exclusive use. Artists in their
attempts to record, more permanently, temporary events,
understood very well the importance of color.
History is an attempt to understand the past in terms
understandable in the present. As our culture changes
we find it more and more difficult to maintain an un-
derstanding of earlier cultures, and much of our histor-
ical information comes from physical objects that have
somehow b een preserved. Especially important to us are
written records. Anyone who visits one of the Egyptian
tombs will have been struck by the use of color that still
appears as bright today as it must have done thousands
of years ago. Color to the Egyptians was not simply
a decoration but was deeply integrated into the nature
of things. Our knowledge of Egyptian color technology,
which was very advanced, is mainly derived from a few
papyri that have somehow survived. It is notable that
natural pigments were supplemented by synthetic ones.
Some of these were produced in high-temperature pro-
cesses as a kind of glass, later ground into a pigment.
Then the Egyptians were perhaps the first to use a series
of pigments known as lakes derived from the residue of
dyeing processes. We still use names like crimson lake in
our paint boxes. Color mixing appears not to have been
practiced to any great extent by the Egyptians, perhaps
because of destructive chemical reaction between many
of their pigments.
Most of the early writings on color contain much that
we would describe as metaphysics and rather less as tech-
nology. Possibly the earliest work that we would recog-
nize as essentially technological was that of Leon Battista
Alberti (1404–1472). Alberti published a book on paint-
ing in 1435. The original was in Latin but was translated
by Alberti into Italian as Della pittura. It was primarily
concerned with the mathematical theory of perspective
but it also contained some information on color mixing
based on the fundamental colors, yellow, blue, green and
red. Although no figure was included in the work, it
was much later assembled by art historians into a dia-
gram that closely resembles the modern CIE L
∗
a
∗
b
∗
color
space.
At what stage color in thin films became important is
unknown, but it must have b een at least observed at a
very early stage. For example, oil and water were com-
mon substances even in prehistory. The trail of a snail
shows color. The exceedingly curious feature of colors
in thin films is that the material of the thin film is it-
self completely devoid of color. The color occurs when
the film acquires a certain minimum thickness and dis-
appears when it has attained a rather greater thickness.
For objective scientific studies of colors in thin films we
must jump to the 17th Century.
2. The 17th to 19th century
In his Micrographia, published in 1665
[1]
, Robert
Hooke (1635–1703) described observations of colors in
thin sheets of mica and between two glass plates pressed
together. He was certainly aware that the colors de-
pended on the thickness of the mica or of the air be-
tween the plates, but could not exactly relate thickness
and color. He did, however, recognize that the thickness
must be within a certain range for the colors to appear.
It was Isaac Newton (1642–1727) who carried out what
appear to be the very first accurate observations of color
related to film thickness. The experiments are described
in detail in Newton’s bo ok Optiks
[2]
published in its first
edition in 1704. Newton even recognized the changes in
color with angle of incidence and his model of colors in
thin films allows us to predict the color of any given film.
Newton’s measurements were so precise that Thomas
Young some 100 years later was able to use them accu-
rately to calculate wavelengths.
It is difficult fully to appreciate the difficulties faced by
these early workers. Newton’s light source was the sun
that shone through a small hole in a screen. His two-
prism experiments had to wait a full year after he had ob-
tained the first until he could obtain a second prism. How
to measure under these circumstances the precise thick-
ness of a thin film? The experiment, known nowadays as
1671-7694/2010/S10001-06
c
° 2010 Chinese Optics Letters