Doubly virtual (π
0
;η;η
0
) → γ
γ
transition form factors
in the light-front quark model
Ho-Meoyng Choi
Department of Physics, Teachers College, Kyungpook National University, Daegu 41566, Korea
Hui-Young Ryu
Department of Physics, Pusan National University, Pusan 46241, Korea
Chueng-Ryong Ji
Department of Physics, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, North Carolina 27695-8202, USA
(Received 5 March 2019; published 19 April 2019)
We report our investigation on the doubly virtual transition form factors (TFFs) F
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ for the
P → γ
ðq
1
Þγ
ðq
2
ÞðP ¼ π
0
; η; η
0
Þ transitions using the light-front quark model (LFQM). Performing a LF
calculation in the exactly solvable manifestly covariant Bethe-Salpeter (BS) model as the first illustration,
we use the q
þ
1
¼ 0 frame and find that both LF and manifestly covariant calculations produce exactly the
same results for F
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ. This confirms the absence of the LF zero mode in the doubly virtual TFFs.
We then map this covariant BS model to the standard LFQM using the more phenomenologically
accessible Gaussian wave function provided by the LFQM analysis of meson mass spectra. For the
numerical analyses of F
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ, we compare our LFQM results with the available experimental data
and the perturbative QCD (pQCD) and vector meson dominance (VMD) model predictions. As
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ → ∞ , our LFQM result for doubly virtual TFF is consistent with the pQCD prediction, i.e.,
F
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ ∼ 1=ðQ
2
1
þ Q
2
2
Þ, while it differs greatly from the result of the VMD model, which behaves
as F
VMD
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ ∼ 1=ðQ
2
1
Q
2
2
Þ. Our LFQM prediction for F
η
0
γ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ shows an agreement with the
very recent experimental data obtained from the BABAR Collaboration for the ranges of
2 < ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ < 60 GeV
2
.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevD.99.076012
I. INTRODUCTION
The meson-photon transitions such as P → γ
ðÞ
γ
ðÞ
ðP ¼
π
0
; η; η
0
Þ with one or two virtual photons have been of
interest to both theoretical and experimental physics
communities since they are the simplest possible bound
state processes in quantum chromodynamics (QCD) and
they play a significant role in allowing both the low- and
high-energy precision tests of the standard model.
In particular, both singly virtual and doubly virtual
transition form factors (TFFs) are required to estimate
the hadronic light-by-light (HLbL) scattering contri-
bution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment
ðg − 2Þ
μ
. The HLbL contribution is in principle obtained
by integrating some weighting functions times the product
of a single-virtual and a double-virtual TFF for spacelike
momentum [1–3]. The single-virtual TFFs have been
measured either from the spacelike e
þ
e
−
→ e
þ
e
−
P process
in the single tag mode [4–6] or from the timelike Dalitz
decays P →
¯
llγ [7–12], where ð2m
l
Þ
2
≤ q
2
≤ m
2
P
. The
timelike region beyond the single Dalitz decays may be
accessed through the e
þ
e
−
→ Pγ annihilation processes,
and the BABAR Collaboration [13] measured the timelike
F
η
ð0Þ
γ
TFFs from the reaction e
þ
e
−
→ η
ð0Þ
γ at an average
e
þ
e
−
center of mass energy of
ffiffiffi
s
p
¼ 10.58 GeV.
Very recently, the BABAR Collaboration [14] measured
for the first time the double-virtual γ
ðq
1
Þγ
ðq
2
Þ → η
0
TFF
F
η
0
γ
ðQ
1
1
;Q
2
2
Þ in the spacelike (i.e., Q
2
1ð2Þ
¼ −q
2
1ð2Þ
> 0)
kinematic region of 2 < ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ < 60 GeV
2
by using the
e
þ
e
−
→ e
þ
e
−
η
0
process in the double-tag mode as shown
in Fig. 1. It is very interesting to note that the measurement
of F
Pγ
ðQ
1
1
;Q
2
2
Þ at large Q
2
1
and Q
2
2
distinguishes the
predictions of the model inspired by perturbative QCD
(pQCD) [15,16], F
pQCD
Pγ
ðQ
2
1
;Q
2
2
Þ∼ 1=ðQ
2
1
þQ
2
2
Þ,fromthose
of the vector meson dominance (VMD) model [17–19],
Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.
Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to
the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation,
and DOI. Funded by SCOAP
3
.
PHYSICAL REVIEW D 99, 076012 (2019)
2470-0010=2019=99(7)=076012(8) 076012-1 Published by the American Physical Society