An assessment of circulation type classifications for precipitation distribution
in Norway
Ole Einar Tveito
Norwegian Meteorological Institute, P.O. Box 43 Blindern, NO-0313 Oslo, Norway
article info
Article history:
Received 3 March 2009
Received in revised form 14 March 2010
Accepted 24 March 2010
Available online 24 April 2010
Keywords:
Weather types
Precipitation
Frequency analysis
Norway
abstract
This paper presents a climatological validation of atmospheric circulation type catalogues included in the
COST 733 dataset (COST733CAT). The circulation type classifications ability to describe patterns of the
Norwegian precipitation climate is analysed. For all 73 classifications included in the COST733CAT sev-
eral statistical measures are calculated for each individual circulation type. These statistics include both
frequencies of precipitation occurrence and statistical moments used to fit
c
-distributions for each circu-
lation type at precipitation stations. In this paper results from four stations in different precipitation
regions and classifications with 9 types are emphasized. The circulation types employed represent
the COST 733 domain 02 (57–72°N, 6°W–25°E).
Precipitation occurrence frequency statistics and probability density functions are used to analyse if the
types within the circulation type classifications can describe different precipitation conditions. Simple
measures are developed in order to compare classifications. The similarity of probability density func-
tions of type specific precipitation within classifications are analysed applying Kolmogorov–Smirnov
tests. The type-specific distribution functions are also compared with the probability function of all pre-
cipitation events. The results reveal that some classifications, particularly those associated with the neu-
ral network methods does not discriminate precipitation distributions very well. On the other side many
classifications performs well and get high scores. Evaluating all 73 catalogues the results indicate best
results for classifications with 27–30 types.
Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The atmospheric circulation has a major influence on regional
and local climate variations. It is well known that the climate de-
pends upon the prevailing winds, e.g. will climatic elements re-
spond differently to advection from a maritime environment
than airflow from a continental area. The influence of atmospheric
circulation can be found on several scales, both temporal and spa-
tial. The variations are most obvious when considering a synoptic
scale. For example will westerly air-flows most likely give precip-
itation along the western coasts of Scotland and Scandinavia (Prud-
homme and Reed, 1998; Tveito et al., 2000). In a similar way will
north-easterly advection most likely result in precipitation in Cen-
tral Europe (Ustrnul and Czekierda, 2001).
Norway is a country with large climate variations. The proxim-
ity to sea and the relief of the country induces large climatological
gradients. Mean annual precipitation varies between less than 300
and more than 4000 mm. The wettest zone in Norway is along the
western coasts were the dominating westerly airflow combined
with a strong orographic influence results in high precipitation
amounts. There are however large variations in the precipitation
patterns with respect to atmospheric circulation and small changes
in the large scale wind direction and wind force results in consid-
erable changes in the spatial distribution of both precipitation
occurrence and precipitation amounts (Hanssen-Bauer and
Førland, 2000; Tveito, 2002).
Due to the influence of the large scale atmospheric circulation
on the regional and local climate variability, classification of the
large scale atmospheric circulation has frequently been used to as-
sess links between atmospheric circulation and climate. Such clas-
sifications of the atmospheric circulation have a long history. There
is a large number of various weather and circulation type classifi-
cations. Yarnal (1993) and Yarnal et al. (2001) gave an overview of
the main concepts of these methods. Manual (subjective) classifi-
cations of weather and circulation types like the classifications of
Wangenheim (1938), Girs (1948), Hess and Brezowsky (1952,
1977), Lamb (1950, 1972) among several others were developed
in the first half of the 20th century. The basic principle of such clas-
sifications is to simplify the complex nature of the dynamic prop-
erties of the atmosphere into discrete categories (circulation types)
by a set of rules. Computer assisted (sometimes referred to as auto-
matic) weather and circulation types classifications have devel-
oped over the last few decades. This group of classifications
1474-7065/$ - see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.pce.2010.03.044
E-mail address: ole.einar.tveito@met.no
Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 35 (2010) 395–402
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Physics and Chemistry of the Earth
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pce