Eur. Phys. J. C (2019) 79:914
https://doi.org/10.1140/epjc/s10052-019-7403-2
Regular Article - Theoretical Physics
On non-perturbative unitarity in gravitational scattering
Ivo Sachs
1,a
, Tung Tran
2,b
1
Arnold Sommerfeld Center for Theoretical Physics, Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich, Theresienstr. 37, 80333 Munich, Germany
2
Albert Einstein Institute, Am Mühlenberg 1, 14476 Potsdam-Golm, Germany
Received: 29 September 2019 / Accepted: 11 October 2019 / Published online: 12 November 2019
© The Author(s) 2019
Abstract We argue that the tree-level graviton-scalar scat-
tering in the Regge limit is unitarized by non-perturbative
effects within General Relativity alone, that is without resort-
ing to any extension thereof. At Planckian energy the back
reaction of the incoming graviton on the background geom-
etry produces a non-perturbative plane wave which softens
the UV-behavior in turn. Our amplitude interpolates between
the perturbative graviton-scalar scattering at low energy and
scattering on a classical plane wave in the Regge limit that is
bounded for all values of s.
1 Introduction
It is well known that perturbative scattering amplitudes
involving gravitons violate the unitarity bound at Planckian
energy even at tree-level. For instance, the scattering ampli-
tude of a graviton and a massless scalar field is given by
[1]
A
tree
=−(ε
1
· ε
3
)
iκ
2
4
su
t
, (1)
where s, t, u are the usual Mandelstam variables and κ is the
dimensionful gravitational coupling, grows without bound
as s increases at fixed t. This state of affairs has given rise
to an extensive activity in searching for a UV-completion of
General Relativity (GR). String theory is one such complete
theory whose legacy rests partly on the fact that it predicts
an amplitude that is perturbatively unitary.
On the other hand, one may question whether the assump-
tion of asymptotic in- and out-states on which (1)isbuilt
holds for gravitons of Planckian energy since Gravity is a
non-linear theory whose coupling strength increases with
energy. One argument in favor of it is that a single graviton
can always be boosted to an inertial frame where its energy is
a
e-mail: ivo.sachs@physik.lmu.de
b
e-mails: tung.tran@physik.uni-muenchen.de; tung.tran@aei.mpg.de
small. However, for a two body scattering with large center
of mass (CoM) energy
√
s, there is no boost for which both
particles have small energy. Thus back-reaction will have to
be taken into account for at least one in-going particle. This
idea is not new. It was explored already many years ago by
’t Hooft [2] and others [3] who replaced an ingoing scalar
of transplanckian energy by a gravitational shock wave. One
may also interpret this back-reaction as a contribution to the
self completeness mechanism of gravity proposed by Dvali
and Gomez [4,5]. The starting point on which we base our
argument for a non-perturbative unitarization of (1) is similar
to [2] although the details are somewhat different. We per-
form a Lorentz boost such that the energy of the incomming
scalar is small while the incomming graviton has transplanck-
ian energy so that back reaction on geometry has to be taken
into account. Luckily, an exact solution to Einstein’s equa-
tion, accounting for the complete back reaction on geometry
is available in the form of a plane wave [6,7](c.f.[8–12]).
As a result, the non-perturbative generalization of (1)inthe
large s but small t (or Regge) limit can be reduced to a per-
turbative calculation on top of a plane wave as illustrated in
Fig. 1.
2 Perturbative limit
To see how this comes about let us first recover the pertur-
bative amplitude (1)for(h
(1)
,φ
(2)
→ h
(3)
,φ
(4)
) in position
space. Without restricting the generality we make the follow-
ing momentum assignments
p
(1)
≡ p = (p
+
, 0, 0, 0), p
(2)
≡ k = (0, k
−
, 0, 0)
p
(3)
≡ q = (q
+
, q
−
, q
1
, q
2
), p
(4)
≡ l = (l
+
, l
−
, l
1
, l
2
).
In position space the t-channel diagram can then be calcu-
lated as follows: We first solve for the internal graviton
˜
h
around Minkowski background, η, through
123