1.2. PHYSICS, MATHEMATICS, AND ENGINEERING 7
wave. It turns out that light also has the properties of particles and can be looked upon as a
stream of photons.
Physicists were also interested in the basic structure of matter. By the early 1900s, it
was recognized that all matter is built from atoms. Every atom has a nucleus consisting
of neutrons and positively charged protons and a number of negatively charged electrons
circling around the nucleus. Although electrons in the form of static electrical charges were
recognized in ancient times, their properties (the amount of charge and mass of each electron)
were exp erimentally measured only in 1897. Furthermore, it was experimentally verified
that the electron, just as light, has the dual properties of wave and particle. These atomic
phenomena were outside the reach of Newton’s laws and Einstein’s theory of relativity but
could be explained using quantum mechanics developed in 1926. By now it is known that
all matters are built from two types of particles: quarks and leptons. They interact with
each other through gravity, electromagnetic interactions, and strong and weak nuclear forces.
In summary, physics tries to develop physical laws to describe natural phenomena and to
uncover the basic structure of matter.
Mathematics is indispensable in physics. Even though physical laws were inspired by
concepts and measurements, mathematics is needed to provide the necessary tools to make
the concepts precise and to derive consequences and implications. For example, Einstein had
some ideas about the general theory of relativity in 1907, but it took him eight years to find
the necessary mathematics to make it complete. Without Maxwell’s equations, EM theory
could not have been developed. Mathematics, however, has developed into its own subject
area. It started with the counting of, perhaps, cows and the measurement of farm lots. It
then developed into a discipline which has little to do with the real world. It now starts with
some basic entities, such as p oints and lines, which are abstract concepts (no physical point
has zero area and no physical line has zero width). One then selects a number of assumptions
or axioms, and then develops logical results. Note that different axioms may lead to different
mathematical branches such as Euclidean geometry, non-Euclidean geometry, and Riemann
geometry. Once a result is proved correct, the result will stand forever and can withstand any
challenge. For example, the Pythagorean theorem (the square of the hypotenuse of a right
triangle equals the sum of the squares of both sides) was first proved about 5 B.C. and is
still valid today. In 1637, Pierre de Fermat claimed that no positive integer solutions exist
in a
n
+ b
n
= c
n
, for any integer n larger than 2. Even though many special cases such as
n = 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, . . . had been established, nobody was able to prove it for all integers n > 2
for over three hundred years. Thus the claim remained a conjecture. It was finally proven
as a theorem in 1994 (see Reference [S3]). Thus, the bottom line in mathematics is absolute
correctness, whereas the bottom line in physics is truthfulness to the physical world.
Engineering is a very broad discipline. Some involve in designing and constructing skyscrap-
ers and bridges; some in developing useful materials; some in designing and building electron-
ics devices and physical systems; and many others. Sending the two exploration rovers to
Mars (launched in Mid 2003 and arrived in early 2004) was also an engineering task. In
this ambitious national project, budgetary concerns were secondary. For most engineering
products, such as motors, CD players and cell phones, cost is critical. To be commercially
successful, such products must be reliable, small in size, high in performance and competitive
in price. Furthermore they may require a great deal of marketing. The initial product design
and development may be based on physics and mathematics. Once a working model is devel-
oped, the model must go through repetitive modification, improvement, and testing. Physics
and mathematics usually play only marginal roles in this cycle. Engineering ingenuity and
creativity play more prominent roles.
Engineering often involves tradeoffs or compromises between performance and cost, and
between conflicting specifications. Thus, there are often similar products with a wide range
in price. The concept of tradeoffs is less eminent in mathematics and physics; whereas it is
an unavoidable part of engineering.
For low-velocity phenomena, Newton’s laws are valid and can never be improved. Maxwell’s
equations describe electromagnetic phenomena and waves and have been used for over one