vacuum permittivity. Noble metals, such as silver and gold, have
relatively high carrier densities exceeding 10
22
cm
3
, locating
their plasma frequencies in a range starts from the ultraviolet
(UV) region to the visible light. TCOs have a lower conductivity
and their carrier density can reach 10
20
–10
21
cm
3
, an order
lower than metals, shifting their plasma frequency to near-
infrared range.
2.2. Epsilon Near Zero (ENZ) Regime
In normal dispersion, the real part of permittivity (e
r
) of material
decreases as wavelength increases. When e
r
decreased from
positive to negative, the wavelength is called as epsilon-near-zero
(ENZ) wavelength. The ENZ wavelength of TCOs, depending on
carrier density and preparation process, is always located in the
near-infrared (NIR) range which is convenient for optical
communication applications. For example, the ENZ wavelength
of a 900 nm thick AZO thin film deposited by PLD is 1410 nm,
[8]
while for a kind of commercial ITO is 1528 nm.
[25]
In the ENZ regime, a strong nonlinear optical coefficient has
been revealed in AZO thin films.
[8]
Suppose n
2
as the nonlinear
refractive index then, the total refractive index can be written as
n ¼ n
0
þ δn
r
, where δn
r
¼ n
2
I. In the ENZ regime, if e
i
is small
enough and consequently the linear refractive n
0
would be tiny,
thus the nonlinear refractive could make a significant effect.
Figure 1a shows more than a 0.4 variation of AZO film refractive
index using pump-probe measurement system, which is
considered as a high change compared to the linear index of
0.09, around 500% of relative changes.
[8]
Another similar
experiment by Z-scan measurement has shown a 170% change
of the linear refractive index in ITO.
[25]
Nonlinearity results
convey that TCOs have a promising future in optical nonlinear
applications.
There are a few zero-index phenomena in TCOs. The phase
velocity v
ph
¼
c
ffiffiffiffi
eμ
p
can exceed c when e 0 in ENZ regime
(μ ¼ 1), where c is the speed of light in vacuum, e and m are
permittivity and permeability, respectively. For instance, the light
with a wavelength range from 1.11 to 1.25 mm exhibits
superluminal in ITO.
[24]
But a large frequency dispersion exists,
there leads to a sub-c group velocity, where v
g
¼
@ω
@k
, indicating
that the speed of energy and information is also lower than light
in TCOs.
If imaginary part of permittivity (e
i
) approaches zero, the
model of permittivity e
jj
0 may occur. According to non-
resource Maxwell equation
[29]
r
~
H ¼ iωe
~
E ð3Þ
the interrelationship between electric and magnetic fields will no
longer exist with an e near zero. A gentle spatial variation of the
magnetic field (left part of Equation 3) corresponds to a dramatic
temporal variation of the electric field (a large
ω in the right part
of Equation 3), thereby space-time decoupling would occur,
[30,31]
which produces a quasi-static electromagnetic wave. Hence, an
electromagnetic wave can be guided through ENZ channel no
matter how the channel is bent or distorted. It is explained that
there is no phase change in the ENZ medium, and the length
from the start to end of the channel can be seen as a point, just as
Figure 1b shows.
[7]
TCOs’ optical losses (corresponding to the
imaginary part of permittivity) are considerably low in their
respective ENZ range. For example, the e
i
of AZO at ENZ regime
is around 0.2, making it a promising future for these “near zero”
applications.
2.3. Surface Plasmon (SP)
Surface plasmon (SP) is a kind of Transverse Magnetic (TM)
wave which is usually occurring at the interface between metal
and dielectric, enabling the material to focus the optical field in a
narrow area around the interface.
[32,33]
By solving Maxwell
equation, we are able to obtain the plasmon wave-vector as
k
SP
¼ k
0
ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
e
m
e
d
e
m
þe
d
q
, where e
m
and e
d
represent for the permittivity of
metals and dielectric, respectively, k
0
is vacuum wavevector of
incident light, k
SP
is SP wave-vector.
[34]
As k
SP
is not equal to that
of incident light in the same dielectric, a prism or grating
coupling is necessary for exciting SP. Once the resonance
condition is satisfied, namely, e
m
þ e
d
¼ 0, the denominator will
approach 0, that means SP resonance will be excited. Due to the
ability to overcome diffraction limit, surface plasmon has the
potential to be the basis of ultra-compact photonic devices. These
Figure 1. Nonlinear and zero-index phenomena in ENZ regime. a) The change of real part of refractive index (δn
r
¼ n
2
I) versus wavelength. In around
1390 nm, the nonlinear refractive index change reaches maxium. Reproduced with permission.
[8]
Copyright 2016, American Physical Society. b) A
schematic view of tunneling effect of ENZ waveguide, where the phase of electromagnetic wave remains unchanged and exhibits “quasi-static”.
Reproduced with permission.
[7]
Copyright 2017, Nature Research.
status
solidi
physica
a
www.advancedsciencenews.com www.pss-a.com
Phys. Status Solidi A 2019, 216, 1700794 © 2019 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim1700794 (3 of 12)