Bioelectromagnetics 21:402^406 (2000)
Review
Human Health Consequences of
Envir o nme nta ll y-M odul ated Gene Expression:
Potential Roles of ELF^EMFInduced Epigenetic
Versus Mutagenic Mechanisms of Disease
y
James E. Trosko*
Department of Pediatrics and Human Development, Michigan State Universit y,
East Lansing , MI
In order to determine if there might be biological and health consequences after exposures to
extremely-low frequency electromagnetic fields (ELF±EMF), either experimentally or epidemio-
logically, mechanistic understanding of the potential means by which any environmental agent can
affect cells in a multicellular organism has to be reviewed. The goal of this limited review is to
demonstrate that, while the prevailing paradigm of the environmentally-induced acute and chronic
diseases involves either cell killing (cytotoxicity) or gene/chromosome mutations (genotoxicity),
alteration of the expression of genetic information at the transcriptional (turning genes ``on'' or
``off''), translational (stabilizing or de-stabilizing the genetic message), or posttranslational
(altering the gene product or protein) levels has the potential to contribute to various diseases. This
latter mechanism, ``epigenetic'' toxicity, unlike the former two which are irreversible, is charac-
terized by threshold-like action, multiple biochemical pathways and chronic, regular exposures to
be effective. Ultimately, epigenetic toxicants affect one of four potential cell states, namely
alteration of cell proliferation, cell differentiation, programmed cell death (apoptosis) or adaptive
responses of differentiated cells. Bioelectromagnetics 21:402±406, 2000.
ß 2000 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Key words: EMF; epigenetic effects; cell-cell communication
INTRODUCTION: BEYOND REDUCTIONALISM;
HUMAN BEINGS ARE MORE THAN THREE
BILLION BASE PAIRS
To date, concerns about the potential health
effects of exposures to extremely-low frequency
electromagnetic ®elds (ELF±EMF) have focused on
damage to DNA (the genetic material) and mutations
leading to diseases such as cancer. Both inherited
mutations and induced somatic mutations (mutations
are irreversible alterations in the genetic information of
our cells; there are approximately 80,000 such pieces
of information in each of 10 10
12
cells of our bodies)
can contribute to cancers. Most research has been
designed to test genotoxicity. The paradigm that
cancers are ``caused'' by agents that damage DNA
and induce mutations has blinded us to other potential
mechanisms by which biological and health effects
could be induced by ELF±EMF.
Human beings are not only the result of 80,000 or
so genes, but also of the delicate orchestration of
speci®c genes that are expressed after the fertilization
of the single cell (egg) by the sperm, homeostatic
interaction of the dividing, differentiating, apoptosing,
and adaptively responding differentiated cells during
embryogenesis, development, adolescence, matura-
tion, and aging. Normal development and health of
any multicellular organism, such as the human being,
is dependent on this homeostatic regulation via three
major forms of communication within and between
cells of the body (extra-, intra-, and intercellular
communication) (Figure 1).
Moreover, our 10 10
12
cells are not just
disorganized, independent cells swimming around
within the skin of our body as if they were a bunch
ß 2000 Wiley-Liss,Inc.
ÐÐÐÐÐÐ
Contract grant sponsor: Electric Power Research Institute;
Contract grant number: EPRI WO8021-19.
y
Review Paper Presented at the 21st Annual Meeting of the
Bioelectromagnetic Society, June 24, 1999.
*Correspondence to: James E. Trosko, Dept. of Pediatrics and
Human Development, 246 National Food Safety and Toxicology
Center, East Lansing, MI 48824. E-mail: trosko@pilot.msu.edu
Received for review 27 August 1999; Final revision received
25 October 1999