1290 IEEE ANTENNAS AND WIRELESS PROPAGATION LETTERS, VOL. 14, 2015
Low RCS Microstrip Patch Antenna Using
Frequency-Selective Surface and
Microstrip Resonator
Ying Liu, Member, IEEE, Yuwen Hao, Hui Wang, Kun Li, and Shuxi Gong
Abstract—A low radar cross section (RCS) microstrip antenna
is proposed and investigated in this letter. This design is based
on implementation of frequency-selective surfaces (FSSs) and mi-
crostrip resonators. By using the FSS ground instead of the solid
metal ground, out-of-band RCS reduction can be realized. More-
over, in-band RCS reduction can be obtained by loading microstrip
resonators. Significant RCS reduction has been accomplished in
the frequency ranges of 3-10 GHz. Compared with the reference
antenna, the simulation results show that RCS reduction of the
proposed antenna in and out of the operation band is as much as
13 and 17 dB, respectively. Measured results satisfactorily agree
with the simulated ones. Radiation performance of the proposed
antenna is preserved compared with the reference antenna.
Index Terms—Frequency-selective surface (FSS), microstrip
patch antenna, microstrip resonator, radar cross s
ection (RCS)
reduction.
I. INTRODUCTION
C
ONSIDERABLE research interest in radar cross section
(RCS) reduction has been triggered by the development
of the modern stealth technology. For
a low observable plat-
form, the antenna scattering signature acts as one of the main
contributors to total RCS. Thus, research on RCS reduction for
antennas is extremely meanin
gful and urgent [1]. Many methods
have been proposed to reduce the RCS of specific objects during
the past decades. Nevertheless, not all conventional techniques
of RCS reduction are suita
ble for antennas. What is worse, some
techniques are effective for reducing the RCS signature for an
antenna, while they may also degrade the antenna’s radiation
characteristics.
Therefore, such strategies cannot be used to re-
duce the RCS of an antenna. To overcome this drawback, var-
ious approaches have been introduced to reduce the RCS of the
special scatte
ring target.
Over the past decades, many novel techniques have been pro-
posed to obtain RCS reduction, such as shaping of targets, using
Manuscript received October 10, 2014; revised December 21, 2014 and Feb-
ruary 04, 2015; accepted February 07, 2015. Date of publication February 10,
2015; date of current version June 02, 2015. This work was supported in part
by the Program for New Century Excellent Talents in University under Grant
NCET-11-0690, the Fundamental Research funds for the Central Universities
under Grant K5051202049, and the National Natural Science Foundation of
China under Grant 61372001.
The authors are with the National Key Laboratory of Antennas and Mi-
crowave Technology, Xidian University, Xidian 710071, China (e-mail:
liuying@mail.xidian.edu.cn).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this letter are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/LAWP.2015.2402292
radar-absorbing materials (RAM) [2], and application of bionics
principle [3]. By subtracting metal areas, RCS reduction can be
achieved [4], [5]. In [6], a novel metamaterial composed of a
double-square-loop structure is applied for RCS reduction. Nev-
ertheless, that approach cannotbeusedinmanyapplications
because of its narrow operating band. Furthermore, electromag-
netic band gap (EBG) structures are widely employed to reduce
RCS. In [7], EBG structures loaded with lumped resistances are
utilized to obtain in-band RCS reduction. On the other hand,
mushroom-like electromagnetic band gap (EBG) structures are
utilized to achieve out-of-band RCS reduction [8], [9]. More-
over, out-of-band RCS reduction can also be realized by loading
FSSs [10].
In this letter, a compact FSS is designed to replace the solid
metal ground for the purpose of the out-of-band RCS reduction.
In addition, two microstrip resonators are designed and opti-
mized to obtain in-band RCS reduction. Furthermore, a better
RCS reduction can be realized by cutting slots on the metal
ground. To verify the reliability and superior performance of the
proposed method, both of the reference and proposed antenna
prototypes are fabricated and tested. All simulation work is ac-
complished by using Ansoft’s High Frequency Solution Solver
(HFSS) software. In Section II, microstrip resonators and com-
pact FSS cells are introduced and designed. Comparisons of two
antennas’ performance are presented in Section III.
II. D
ESIGN OF THE PROPOSED ANTENNA
A. M icrostrip Resonators
In [11], a simple and meaningful theory based on the cavity
model is introduced to analyze the behavior of microstrip res-
onators. With proper
design, microstrip resonators can operate
at the same frequency as the so-called microstrip antennas. Fur-
thermore, a microstrip antenna can be used as a resonant cavity.
In other words,
it has the ability to store electromagnetic en-
ergy of an irradiated plane wave. Based on this characteristic,
the microstrip resonators have the potential for in-band RCS re-
duction. To
achieve the goal of in-band RCS reduction by using
microstrip resonators, the size of the microstrip resonators and
square-microstrip antenna should be the same. Due to the asym-
metric
structure of the antenna and the effect of the patch on the
microstrip resonators, w, w1, and w2 have different values. In
Fig. 1, geometries of the antenna with and without microstrip
res
onators are provided. For comparisons, the reference antenna
operating at 5 GHz is designed. For a microstrip antenna, a too
1536-1225 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.