Thermal-aware P/G TSV planning for IR drop reduction in 3D ICs
Zuowei Li
a
, Yuchun Ma
a,
n
, Qiang Zhou
a
, Yici Cai
a
, Yuan Xie
b
, Tingting Huang
c
a
Department of Computer Science and Technology, Tsinghua University, Beijing
b
Pennsylvania State University, USA
c
National Tsinghua University, Taiwan
article info
Available online 26 May 2012
Keywords:
Thermal
Power/Ground network
IR drop
TSV
3D IC
abstract
With the leakage-thermal dependency, the increasing on-chip temperature in 3D designs has serious
impact on IR drop due to the increased wire resistance and increased leakage current. Therefore, it is
necessary to consider Power/Ground network design with thermal effects in 3D designs. Though Power/
Ground (P/G) TSV can help to relieve the IR drop violation by vertically connecting on-chip P/G
networks on different layers, most previous work restricts the uniform P/G grids so that the potential of
P/G TSV planning has not been fully explored. In this paper, we present an efficient thermal-aware P/G
TSV planning algorithm based on a sensitivity model with temperature-dependent leakage current
considered. Non-uniform P/G grid topology is explored to optimize the P/G network by allowing short
wires to connect the P/G TSVs to P/G grids. Both the theoretical analysis and experimental results show
the efficiency of our approach. Results show that neglecting thermal impacts on power delivery can
underestimate IR drop by about 11%. To relieve the severe IR drop violation, 51.8% more P/G TSVs are
needed than the cases without thermal impacts considered. Results also show that our P/G TSV
planning based on the sensitivity model can reduce m ax IR drop by 42.3% and reduce the number of
violated nodes by 82.4%.
& 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Recently, through-silicon via (TSV) based 3D IC designs emerge
as a promising solution because of many benefits such as wire
length reduction, smaller form factors, and heterogeneous inte-
gration [1–4]. Due to the increased power density, the tempera-
ture distribution varies a lot between layers in 3D chips. The
imbalance of power distribution among layers results in not only
the various temperature distributions, but also quite different
distributions of IR drops on different layers. The power grid on a
layer is usually a metal mesh. It distributes power and ground
voltages from pad locations to chip cells. Currents drawn from the
package pads flow on the metal stripes to current loadings. This
will cause some voltage drops (IR drops) on the branch because of
the metal resistance. In 3D ICs, it tends to appear different IR
drops on different layers. Under such circumstance, P/G TSVs can
be allocated between adjacent layers to relieve the IR drop
violations. According to different fabrication processes, as
shown in Fig.1, the P/G-network structures in 3D ICs can be
classified into three major schemes: (a) connected (P/G TSVs are
used to connect different P/G networks on adjacent layers);
(b) non-connected (P/G network on each layer is connected to
the package IO directly by wire bonding, there is no directed
connection between P/G networks); and (c) a combination of
connected and non-connected P/G networks. It is obvious that
(c) is the most flexible among the three structures.
In this work, we focus on the structure as shown in Fig.1(c).
Therefore, the P/G network design in 3D ICs is no longer several
separated 2D designs on an individual layer, but a 3D P/G network
should be constructed with P/G TSVs so that the IR drop
distribution on multiple layers can be optimized at the same
time. Currently, only a few works have explored 3D P/G network
design. The related works can be divided into two categories by
their optimization objectives. The first category focuses on the
reduction of power supply noise [5–13]. For example, decoupling
capacitors (decaps) can be used during placement to reduce the
power supply noise [5–9]. In addition to using decaps to reduce
P/G noise, the density of P/G TSVs can be adjusted to reduce the
power supply noise [13]. The second category considers the IR
drop in 3D ICs during early stages. A 3D floorplan and P/G
network co-synthesis tool was proposed to explore the floor-
planning and P/G network topology design with IR drop con-
straint considered [14]. Since TSVs go through the silicon layer,
the distribution of P/G TSVs is influenced by not only the power
distribution but also the whitespace distribution around circuit
modules. In this paper, we further explore P/G TSV planning
Contents lists available at SciVerse ScienceDirect
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/vlsi
INTEGRATION, the VLSI journal
0167-9260/$ - see front matter & 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.vlsi.2012.05.002
n
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: myc@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn (Y. Ma).
INTEGRATION, the VLSI journal 46 (2013) 1–9