为什么Decision Tree Accuracy: 1.0 Support Vector Machine Accuracy: 1.0
时间: 2024-06-03 18:12:49 浏览: 15
Decision Tree和SVM两种算法在处理数据时,都会根据数据的特征和标签进行分类或回归预测。如果训练集和测试集中的数据都很好地符合这些特征和标签,那么这些算法的准确率就会很高,甚至可能达到100%。
但是,在实际应用中,数据往往是复杂和噪声干扰的,这时候算法的准确率就会降低。因此,如果仅仅是在一个小的数据集上测试这些算法,可能会出现准确率高的情况。为了更准确地评估算法的性能,应该使用更多的数据和交叉验证等技术来评估算法。
相关问题
如何解决Decision Tree Accuracy: 1.0 Support Vector Machine Accuracy: 1.0
如果您的决策树和支持向量机(SVM)的准确度都达到了1.0,这意味着它们在训练数据上表现得非常好,但是在测试数据上可能会出现过拟合(overfitting)的情况。您可以尝试以下方法来解决这个问题:
1. 数据集划分:将数据集分成训练集和测试集,使用训练集进行模型训练,使用测试集进行模型评估。这可以帮助您确保模型在新数据上的泛化能力。
2. 交叉验证:通过交叉验证技术,将数据集分成k个子集,每次使用其中一个子集作为测试集,剩余子集作为训练集进行模型训练和评估。这可以帮助您更好地评估模型的性能。
3. 特征选择:考虑对特征进行选择或提取,以减少可能导致过拟合的噪声特征。
4. 调整模型参数:尝试调整模型参数,以使其更好地适应数据集。例如,对于决策树,您可以尝试更改树的深度或分裂标准,对于SVM,您可以尝试更改核函数或正则化参数。
5. 集成方法:考虑使用集成方法,如随机森林或梯度提升树,来使模型更加稳健。
请注意,如果您的数据集非常小,可能会很难避免过拟合,因为您没有足够的数据来支持模型的泛化能力。在这种情况下,您可能需要收集更多的数据或使用更简单的模型。
Exercise#1: Decision Tree and support vector machine. Goal Implement the decision tree algorithm and the support vector machine, respectively and compare their performances. Dataset (in folder ‘data1’) We will use the Adult dataset whose description is available here. The training set (adult.data) and evaluation set (adult.test) can be downloaded here. The prediction task is to determine whether a person makes over 50K a year. Preprocessing Remove all the records containing '?' (i.e., missing values). Also, remove the attribute "native-country". you can not use pandas, DecisionTreeClassifier and SVC
Okay, let's get started with implementing the decision tree and support vector machine algorithms for the given dataset.
First, we need to preprocess the dataset by removing all the records containing '?' and the attribute "native-country". Here's the code for that:
```python
def preprocess(filename):
data = []
with open(filename, 'r') as f:
for line in f:
if '?' in line:
continue
line = line.strip().split(',')
del line[14]
data.append(line)
return data
train_data = preprocess('data1/adult.data')
test_data = preprocess('data1/adult.test')
```
Now that we have preprocessed the dataset, we can move on to implementing the decision tree algorithm. Here's the code for that:
```python
import math
def entropy(data):
counts = {}
for row in data:
label = row[-1]
if label not in counts:
counts[label] = 0
counts[label] += 1
entropy = 0
for label in counts:
p = counts[label] / len(data)
entropy -= p * math.log2(p)
return entropy
def split_data(data, attribute):
splits = {}
for row in data:
value = row[attribute]
if value not in splits:
splits[value] = []
splits[value].append(row)
return splits
def choose_attribute(data):
best_gain = 0
best_attribute = None
for attribute in range(len(data[0]) - 1):
splits = split_data(data, attribute)
entropy_sum = 0
for value in splits:
p = len(splits[value]) / len(data)
entropy_sum += p * entropy(splits[value])
gain = entropy(data) - entropy_sum
if gain > best_gain:
best_gain = gain
best_attribute = attribute
return best_attribute
def majority_label(data):
counts = {}
for row in data:
label = row[-1]
if label not in counts:
counts[label] = 0
counts[label] += 1
majority_label = None
majority_count = 0
for label in counts:
if counts[label] > majority_count:
majority_label = label
majority_count = counts[label]
return majority_label
def decision_tree(data):
if len(data) == 0:
return None
if len(set(row[-1] for row in data)) == 1:
return data[0][-1]
attribute = choose_attribute(data)
if attribute is None:
return majority_label(data)
tree = {attribute: {}}
splits = split_data(data, attribute)
for value in splits:
tree[attribute][value] = decision_tree(splits[value])
return tree
```
Now that we have implemented the decision tree algorithm, we can move on to implementing the support vector machine algorithm. Here's the code for that:
```python
import random
def dot_product(x, y):
return sum(xi * yi for xi, yi in zip(x, y))
def svm_train(data, epochs, learning_rate):
w = [0] * len(data[0][:-1])
b = 0
for epoch in range(epochs):
random.shuffle(data)
for row in data:
x = row[:-1]
y = row[-1]
if y * (dot_product(w, x) + b) <= 1:
w = [wi + learning_rate * (y * xi - 2 * 0.1 * wi) for wi, xi in zip(w, x)]
b += learning_rate * y
else:
w = [(1 - 2 * 0.1 * learning_rate) * wi for wi in w]
return w, b
def svm_predict(data, w, b):
predictions = []
for row in data:
x = row[:-1]
y = row[-1]
if dot_product(w, x) + b > 0:
predictions.append(1)
else:
predictions.append(-1)
return predictions
```
Finally, we can compare the performances of the decision tree and support vector machine algorithms on the given dataset. Here's the code for that:
```python
train_data = [(list(map(float, row[:-1])), 1 if row[-1] == '>50K' else -1) for row in train_data]
test_data = [(list(map(float, row[:-1])), 1 if row[-1] == '>50K.' else -1) for row in test_data]
tree = decision_tree(train_data)
tree_predictions = [evaluate(tree, row[:-1]) for row in test_data]
tree_accuracy = sum(1 for prediction, actual in zip(tree_predictions, test_data) if prediction == actual[-1]) / len(test_data)
svm_w, svm_b = svm_train(train_data, epochs=100, learning_rate=0.01)
svm_predictions = svm_predict(test_data, svm_w, svm_b)
svm_accuracy = sum(1 for prediction, actual in zip(svm_predictions, test_data) if prediction == actual[-1]) / len(test_data)
print('Decision Tree Accuracy:', tree_accuracy)
print('Support Vector Machine Accuracy:', svm_accuracy)
```
This should give us the accuracy of the decision tree and support vector machine algorithms on the given dataset.
相关推荐
![pdf](https://img-home.csdnimg.cn/images/20210720083512.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)
![](https://csdnimg.cn/download_wenku/file_type_ask_c1.png)